A brand that runs frequent sales often ends up with the same worry. Customers seem to stop buying between promotions and come back the day the next one starts.
The question of whether discounts train customers to wait is not new. Marketing researchers have studied it with years of household purchase data, field experiments and one very public retail reversal, and the answer is mostly yes, with some useful limits.
Key Takeaways
- Long-run studies of household panel data find shoppers become more price and promotion sensitive as promotions increase.
- Heavier promotion exposure has been linked to households buying less often and stocking up when deals arrive.
- A field experiment found deeper discounts lifted future purchases by new customers but reduced them for established ones.
- Pulling discounts away abruptly from customers used to them can be costly, as J.C. Penney found in 2012.
- Playably runs one alternative, a full-price offer where shoppers can win their order back if a real-world event happens.
What the long-run studies found
The clearest evidence comes from studies that followed the same households for years. Mela, Gupta and Lehmann analyzed more than eight years of panel data for a frequently purchased packaged good, published in the Journal of Marketing Research in 1997.
They found consumers became more sensitive to price and promotions over time. The authors linked the shift to falling advertising and rising promotions over the same period.
A follow-up study looked at timing rather than sensitivity. Mela, Jedidi and Bowman studied more than eight years of purchases in a nonfood packaged-goods category and found that as households saw more promotions over the long run, they became less likely to buy the category on a given shopping trip.
When those households did buy, they bought larger quantities. The authors read the pattern as shoppers increasingly waiting for especially good deals, with harmful effects on category profitability.
That is the behavior brands describe. Shoppers learn the rhythm of the promotions and time their purchases to it.
Which customers learn to wait
The effect is not the same for everyone. Anderson and Simester ran three field experiments with a catalog retailer, published in Marketing Science in 2004.
Deeper discounts increased future purchases by first-time customers. The same deeper discounts reduced future purchases by established customers.
The authors pointed to several mechanisms, including forward buying, customer learning and increased deal sensitivity. For a DTC brand, the practical reading is that a discount used to win a first order behaves differently from one sent repeatedly to loyal buyers.
Where the research pushes back
Not every study finds lasting damage. Pauwels, Hanssens and Siddarth modeled weekly scanner data for a storable and a perishable product and found that permanent effects of price promotions were virtually absent.
Sales components moved for a while after each promotion and then settled back. A single promotion, on that evidence, does not permanently change how customers buy.
The difference between the studies is mostly about frequency and time horizon. One promotion fades, while years of steady promotion appear to reshape what shoppers expect.
What happens when a retailer stops
J.C. Penney tested the reverse in 2012, replacing much of its sales calendar with everyday pricing. For the full fiscal year, comparable store sales fell 25.2 percent and the company lost $985 million.
The company changed many things at once, so the numbers do not isolate the pricing decision. They do show that customers used to sales did not simply accept a lower everyday price instead.
The lesson for a smaller brand is that the habit is real on both sides. Training customers to wait takes years, and untraining them abruptly can cost more than the discounts did.
What brands are trying instead
Some brands are testing offers that give shoppers a reason to buy now without lowering the price. Playably runs gamified conditional rebates for Shopify brands, tied to a real, published event such as a sports result or a weather event.
Shoppers buy at full price and are entered automatically. If the trigger hits, Playably pays them 100% of their order back by Venmo or PayPal, usually within days, and Playably insures and hedges the payout so the brand pays $0 of the rebate.
Playably reports one result that speaks to the waiting problem. In Jordan Craig’s NFL Draft campaign, 93% of buyers walked past two 25%-off sitewide sales running the same month, and baskets ran 34% bigger than the store average at full price.
That is one brand and one campaign, not a controlled study. It suggests that a reason to buy now does not have to be a lower price.
What this means for a promotion calendar
The studies point to three habits worth checking in any brand’s calendar.
- Predictable timing. A sale that lands on the same dates every year is the easiest rhythm for shoppers to learn, so the research suggests varying when promotions run.
- Who receives the discount. The Anderson and Simester results suggest a deep discount pays back on first orders and costs money on repeat buyers, so segment before sending.
- How often the price drops. The long-run panel studies tie rising sensitivity to years of steady promotion, not to one event, so count how many weeks a year the full price is actually charged.
None of this argues for never promoting. It argues for treating each discount as something customers will remember the next time they consider paying full price.
The short version
The research supports the worry, with limits. Frequent, predictable promotions make shoppers more price sensitive and teach them to time purchases, while a single promotion largely fades.
Brands can act on that without abandoning promotions. Keep discounts aimed at first orders, make timing less predictable, and test offers that hold the price for established customers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do discounts train customers to wait for sales?
Discounts can train customers to wait when they run often and predictably. Long-run panel studies in the Journal of Marketing Research found shoppers became more promotion sensitive as promotions increased, and households bought less often while stocking up when deals appeared.
Do discounts hurt loyal customers more than new ones?
Deeper discounts appear to affect established customers more. A 2004 field experiment in Marketing Science found deeper discounts increased future purchases by first-time customers but reduced future purchases by established customers of the same retailer.
How can a brand promote without training customers to wait?
A brand can limit discounts to first orders, vary when promotions run, and use offers that keep the price intact. Playably’s conditional rebate is one example, where shoppers pay full price and get their order back only if a published event happens.
Terry Clark is the Publisher and Content Director of 365 Retail, with more than a decade of experience covering retail design, technology innovations, store openings and the wider retail industry. He also works closely with leading retailers, suppliers, agencies, events and industry awards across the UK.






















